A valuation is only as reliable as the asset register underneath it — and in practice, asset registers frequently diverge from what's physically on the ground, sometimes significantly.
Why physical verification matters
Fixed asset registers accumulate errors over time: assets disposed of but never removed from the register, assets relocated between sites without being updated, assets double-counted following mergers, and assets never properly recorded at acquisition. A valuation performed purely from register data without physical verification inherits every one of these errors.
What a proper verification process includes
- Physical tagging and matching. Each asset should carry a unique identifier that can be physically matched during a site visit — mismatches are flagged immediately.
- Condition assessment at the point of verification. The site visit is also the opportunity to assess actual condition against assumed condition — critical for accurate depreciation.
- Location reconciliation. Confirming the asset is where the register says it is — assets frequently migrate between sites without paperwork catching up.
- Reconciliation reporting. Assets confirmed, assets not found (write-off candidates), assets found but not on register, and discrepancies in location, quantity, or specification.
The audit relevance
External auditors reviewing fixed asset balances increasingly expect evidence of periodic physical verification, not just register review — particularly for high-value plant and machinery balances. A valuation report that references recent physical verification carries materially more weight, both for audit purposes and internal asset management.
Practical recommendation
For any significant plant and machinery valuation exercise, budget for physical verification as part of the scope rather than treating it as optional — the cost is modest relative to the risk of a valuation built on an unreliable asset base, and the resulting reconciliation report has standalone value for internal control purposes beyond the valuation itself.